Monday, May 7, 2007

2007 U.S. Championship-5

Okay, the Chess Goddess has come through again :) I asked for more information, and I found some - today - at Mig's Daily Dirt. Thanks, Chess Goddess, you are the greatest. John Donaldson posted the following: The US Championship has recently been increased to $70,000. Additionally there are daily $100 most interesting game prizes decided by a vote of the public over the Internet and the return of the Crenshaw special game prize. The first five finishers advance in the FIDE World Championship cycle. The next five receive free room and board at the Continental Championship. The National Open is offering several prizes. The hotel in Stillwater is half the cost of San Diego and the organizers are ferrying the players 70 miles from Tulsa to Stillwater. Only 3 spots were assigned to women ( there will be a ten players womens event in July - also in Stillwater. We are very lucky to have the Berrys).Krush accepted immediately. For various reasons, principally work and school, many declined until Iryna Zenyuk and Chouchan Airapetian accepted. Considering that two months ago it looked like there would be no US Championship things look very good, particularly as it was not easy for many folks to make arrangements on such short notice. They will be treated very well by Jim and Frank Berry. I hope that Joel Ripken-Gehrig Benjamin returns next year! Posted by: John Donaldson at May 7, 2007 14:07 *********************************************************************************** I checked earlier today and could not find any of this information posted at the USCF website (what's new?) So - we now know that there will be 10 women playing in the Women's Championship - we just don't know who they are yet - except that they won't be any of the higest rated women players in the United States. We also know that - since it doesn't seem very likely anyone else will come forward with a "bid" at this late date (particularly since bids haven't been been solicited), the Berry brothers will host the Women's event in Stillwater. I'm glad a Women's championship will be held, after all, but I'm sad because this is certainly a much diminished event from the ones hosted by AF4C the past several years - and I'm not just talking about the prize money. Some random thoughts:
  • So the prize fund for the "Men's" event has been increased to $70,000. Either Mr. Berry has found one or more additional sponsors, which is always good news, or the USCF has been shamed into kicking in another $5,000 from the $25,000 that Erik Anderson contributed to the USCF that, as I understand it, was specifically to be used for prize money for the 2007 U.S. Chess Championsips when AF4C and USCF said adieu.
  • The first five finishers advance to the FIDE Championship cycle? Oh for goodness sake - well, I suppose that could be a "carrot" for some players. The better carrot is the offer of free room and board at the next Continental Championship for players 5 through 10. Now THAT has a monetary value to it, and it's far more realistic that American players who, lets face it, except for Gata Kamsky and Irina Krush, are not exactly playing in the European circuit, will find that a prize of value.
  • Will the tempting "second level" prize (the free room and board for 5 members at the next Continental) cause a bunch of late-level draws where wins would otherwise be at hand? Or, even worse, losses? Ohmygoddess! Can you see it - players battling for the 5th through 10th spots on the final board???
  • Where's the money coming from for the daily $100 most interesting game prize?
  • Who the heck is Crenshaw?

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

it would of been nice for the uscf to accept my 10,000 offer to play, with at least another 10,000 next year. This might of made up for the 250,000 they rejected last year. So it seems that my support of susan lost me a place in the us cahpionship. Thats why a change in mgt is needed.

Jan said...

Dr. Moskow, it's ridiculous that the USCF refused to give you a spot, after openly soliciting players such as yourself to pay to play! If the refusal was done for political reasons, that is all the more despicable. Change in management at USCF is definitely in order!

OkieLawyer said...

I talked with Jim Berry and the reason Mr. Moskow was not allowed to play is because he insisted on being able to play from home via the internet. Mr. Berry informed me that FIDE rules do not allow such an arrangement.

Jan said...

Hi Okie Lawyer,

Yes, thanks for confirming the info. I learned more information since I made my comment under this post (I posted elsewhere on this blog about the topic) on May 13. Much has been written about this event by Dr. Moskow and others at Susan Polgar's blog and Mig's Daily Dirt, and Dr. Moskow also made a post at McClain's new chess blog at the New York Times. I believe I now have a basic understanding of what took place and why Dr. Moskow's request was turned down by USCF. This is not to say that I think Dr. Moskow was unqualified to participate in the event, given the fact that USCF did solicit patrons to pay to play, and by virtue of Dr. Moskow's experience and ELO, he would be as competitive as several other players currently playing in Stillwater. It is too bad that things could not be worked out, but under the circumstances I do now understand why playing the games on computer would not have worked.

Thanks again!

P.S. I stand by my prior comment that a change in management at USCF is definitely in order!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...